The mystery contractor defence simply doesn’t cut it
Racing’s sad scandal cannot end with the blame falling at the feet of a mystery contractor.
The tragedy surrounding So You Are is racing’s biggest scandal in years and all we have to blame, as it stands, is a truck driver who we’re told disposed of a Melbourne Cup runner incorrectly.
Racing as an industry deserves better.
The shameful treatment of the Cup runner is a global story that demands significant consequences. We are not agitating for a scalp, just answers and, if appropriate, justice.
The gut-wrenching saga plays into everything racing is accused of by its critics – the animals, the heroes of our sport, loved by those who train them – are disposable.
Once they have raced, we simply cast them aside for the next animal to bet on.
The thesis is wrong, of course.
But the story has gone around the world – even celebrity publisher TMZ, which is more likely to cover Kim Kardashian than horse racing, featured it on Tuesday.
But has the industry done enough to quell the anger or explain the path forward?
Firstly, the company responsible for the shameful episode, REC Equine Specialists, should be held to greater account.
Some on Tuesday were congratulating the veterinary service for taking responsibility and apologising. A select few even appeared to justify the error.
Excuse the cynicism, but saying sorry has to be the bare minimum.
To then blame an unnamed contractor is cowardly at best.
Some REC staff involved in the saga should also take a long, hard look at themselves – speculation persists a few showed borderline apathy before the story broke. Fair to say they now feel differently.
Who takes responsibility? Who pays the price for one of racing’s biggest black eyes?
The politicising of it by some as some kind of state-versus-state battle is not surprising, but still shameful.
I am not the type to seek scalps in a crisis, but this is not an episode that should simply be put down to a rogue contractor doing the wrong thing.
Racing needs leadership and to reassure the casual racing follower that action will be taken.
If Racing Australia ever wants to prove its relevance, it’s now.
It should be leading the way in creating a national set of guidelines that ensures a mess like this never happens again. It’s my understanding there is an appetite for this to happen.
That would ensure the public message is clear – the racing industry is angry too, we do care for our animals and we get the outrage.
It’s hard to surmise where this sorry saga will leave racing once the news cycle moves on. I have covered enough scandals and tragedy to learn to never make wild predictions while emotions are high and adrenaline is pumping.
But what is clear is that the damage is real, just how long lasting is harder to ascertain.
And while private legal action is almost a certainty – it shouldn’t be the only consequence REC faces for its appalling work.
An argument So You Are’s anguished owner Stuart Ramsey agrees with.
”As I’ve told them; it wasn’t the contractor’s fault; it was their fault. They were in charge of the horse,” he told racenet.
“I’m still convinced they don’t understand the gravity of it all and what this is doing to people’s lives.
“We should have been given the opportunity to take him to our farm and bury him. We would have done that for sure.”

Typically, at race clubs, once your carnival is run and won, staff can relax somewhat and even head off for some much-deserved time off.
For the folk at the VRC, that just doesn’t seem possible.
After an amazing Melbourne Cup Carnival, the club has had to deal with a vicious and somewhat embarrassing board battle.
Then this week, they were victims of a brazen theft of three Melbourne Cups on Monday.
And things don’t look like getting any quieter.
Interviews for potential board candidates are taking place this week as chairman Neil Wilson retires.
What appears to be clear, however, is that there could be some kind of peace pipe being passed around the hallowed boardroom table.
While there still appears to be bad blood between some of the board, some who voted for Michael Ramsden to become the new chairman [a vote he lost to Vin Cox] are now less than impressed with the behaviour of some of his key supporters.
As we’ve written twice now, the adults in the saga are seeking a palatable way forward.
The result, we’re told, is some kind of truce. Ramsden appears on the outer of sorts, and work is being done on how the board will look and operate post the election.
Kanga is a short-priced favourite to be voted on – Betsy understands he recently caught up with Cox – but that hasn’t stopped some at the club seeking a different candidate they could tell members will have board support in the hope of stopping the former MRC chairman.
Betsy is aware of several high-profile racing candidates that were approached to run, but declined.
Rumours persist that some centerd on an interstate candidate as the answer – surely with all the Melbourne ‘elite’ and powerful scheming, they could find someone who knows where Epsom Road is?
After all, those opposing Cox point out the fact he is based in Queensland [a factor we reckon is a non-issue, we’d swap Bourke Street for Broadbeach any day].
We’ve previously noted that there was a Melbourne Cup-sized field wanting to nominate.
That field is now more Cox Plate-sized – around 11 or so – and a few still dropping off. From failed police checks to others simply withdrawing.
The interview process will possibly knock a few off. Some, fearing unfair treatment by the interview panel, have already engaged powerful legal types to act if necessary.
Given the tragedy of So You Are – and despite your humble columnist continuing to write about it – elements of the spectacle of the weeks pass look incredibly juvenile and irrelevant considering.

WA Tote sale talk heats up
All eyes are on what the Western Australian Government does with its tote, amid expectations it will be separated from the state’s racing regulator.
The wagering industry is of the view that Tabcorp is being favoured to buy the tote, given its retail network and experience operating tote businesses.
But Betsy understands Tabcorp is yet to decide whether it has any interest.
If the WA Government decides to seek a buyer, the sale is expected to go through a tender process, an issue many had been debating.
The Tote was previously put up for sale, with Betr bidding $1 billion ahead of Entain.
The sale process was eventually shut down by the government.
It comes as the wagering industry waits on several important reviews out of the west, which will help determine how heavily bookmakers invest in the state.
Racing Queensland’s big call looms
The battle for the top-job at Racing Queensland is nearing completion.
As Betsy revealed this week, it’s down to current acting CEO and local hope Lachlan Murray and former Melbourne Racing Club CEO Josh Blanksby.
The board is now expecting to meet next week to ratify their choice before it then heads to the state government to be ratified.
Depending on who you listen to, it’s a call the government are watching closely.
It’s a two-horse race for the top job at Racing Queensland
https://t.co/bQXDCOveCZ
— Betsy (@betsy_com_au) November 16, 2026
Cup hero’s emotional reunion
Fresh of his heroics, Melbourne Cup winning jockey went back to the medical team that saved his life following a horrific fall in 2023.
Brown posted to his social media this week he took his Cup back to the medical team at Royal Melbourne Hospital to thank them.
‘’Very fitting returning to the Royal Melbourne Hospital today to pay my respects to the surgeons and doctors who saved my life back in 2023. Words were beyond me, but very grateful to say the least🏆💙🩵,’’ Brown wrote.
Brown also visited a local primary school to meet some ‘’young racing enthusiasts’’.
View this post on Instagram
Race on for top job
Is one high-profile racing administrator in the running for the newly available Australian GP CEO role?




