From the Railway Stakes in Perth to The Gong at Kembla Grange and the Cranbourne Cup, Beirne has crunched the ratings and assessed the likely race shapes.
And while he’s happy to trust a Cox Plate winner travelling across the country, two other big names have some questions to answer at their current prices.
Railway Stakes: Class should prevail
There are always questions when a horse travels across the country, particularly when it is lining up for the ninth run of a preparation.
But Shaun Beirne isn’t overly concerned about either factor when it comes to Cox Plate winner Cosmic Crusader, despite it being his ninth run for the campaign!
The star galloper has been one of the stories of the spring, adding two other Group 1 weight-for-age victories to his Cox Plate triumph, and Beirne sees little evidence that his performances are starting to taper off.
“I like him. Obviously he needs to cross the country and show up over the mile, but after winning a Cox Plate and two other Group 1 weight-for-age races this spring, there is no sign of his ratings dipping,” Beirne said.
While some punters might be wary of a horse having its ninth start of the campaign, Beirne points to Cosmic Crusader’s previous preparations as evidence that he can sustain his form.
“In his second career preparation he raced five times and last preparation he raced seven times. In neither of those did his ratings taper away, so I have no issue with him presenting ninth-up.”
The obvious danger is King Of Light, the emerging four-year-old who has won eight of his nine starts and continues to produce impressive late sectionals.
But there is a potential tactical advantage for the Cox Plate winner. King Of Light looks likely to settle behind Cosmic Crusader in the run, meaning he’ll need to produce those powerful closing splits to reel in a horse who has already proven himself against the best.
“On pure ratings Cosmic Crusader would be much shorter. I’m happy he can overcome everything else,” Beirne said.
The verdict: BACK Cosmic Crusader
The Gong:
Few horses could claim to have been more unlucky in their most recent start than Gringotts.
The talented gelding endured a torrid passage in the Big Dance, with a protest from fifth against the winner ultimately upheld.
But while there is a strong case that Gringotts should have finished much closer, Beirne isn’t convinced that makes him an automatic bet in Saturday’s Gong.
In fact, he sees several reasons to oppose him.
“Gringotts was very unlucky in the Big Dance, with the protest from fifth against first upheld,” Beirne said.
“But he’s drawn to be down on the fence again. Is that going to be the best place late in the day? And is he going to have traffic issues again?”
Those are significant questions in what shapes as a deep and competitive race.
A low draw can be an advantage, but it can also leave a horse needing luck at precisely the wrong time, particularly if the inside lanes are no longer the preferred ground.
And with Gringotts potentially needing to navigate traffic once again, Beirne believes the market is giving him too much credit for what might have been last start.
“On ratings, and with those queries, he’s a clear risk in a deep race.”
Importantly, this isn’t a knock on Gringotts’ ability. It’s a question of whether his price adequately reflects the risks.
Bet Legends special: Gringotts to finish 1st or 2nd at $2.30
Cranbourne Cup:
Warnie has been knocking on the door throughout the spring and could easily have another couple of wins beside his name with a little more luck.
But Saturday’s Cranbourne Cup presents another potentially awkward assignment.
The talented galloper has again drawn low, and while that might look favourable on paper, Beirne believes it could prove problematic for a horse who does his best work when building momentum.
“Warnie has been unlucky and could easily have won a couple more races this preparation,” Beirne said.
“He’s again drawn low, which isn’t ideal for a momentum horse. He should be able to stay off the rail, which they’ll likely be getting away from late, but that’s not a given.”
The concern isn’t necessarily that Warnie can’t win. It’s that he might need a few things to fall into place to justify his position towards the top of the market.
And Beirne’s ratings suggest this is a far more open contest than the betting would have you believe.
“On ratings, I have this $7 the field, so at $4.40 he represents no value.”
That’s a sizeable discrepancy between the market and Beirne’s assessment.
In a race where several runners have legitimate winning claims, taking a short price about a horse who may need luck in running isn’t an attractive proposition.
Bet Legends special: Warnie to finish 1st or 2nd at $4.40







